Jump to content
Bullnose Forums

3G Alternator Conversion Page Upgrade.


Recommended Posts

Guys - As said on another thread, I'm wanting to upgrade the 3G Alternator Conversion page. And there are at least two areas to address - what donor vehicles have the 3G's we want, and what to do about the ammeter.

So, let's start with the donor vehicles. The page says:

Vehicles that are donors:

90-99 Taurus/Sable (the 3.8L has 8.125” mounting. 3.0L has the 7” mount spacing) *Need to confirm this info.

91-96 Lincoln V6

94-95 Mustang 5.0L

94-00 Mustang V6

95-96 Windstar V6

94-96 Thunderbird/Cougar 3.8L

92-96 F-Series and E-Series

However, I don't think that is completely accurate. And, it is confusing as it doesn't say which are the 90A and which are the 130A units.

According to our new Alternator Interchange page I get what's shown below. It shows that there are two different 130A alternators used across the above applications. And I am seeing that our previous list is flawed. First, both the 3.0 and 3.8L engines used the same alternator. But, is it the 8.25" or the 7". Surely it is the 8.25" - right? And, the year ranges aren't accurate.

So, is there any reason not to put this table in place of the previous list?

And, do we want to say anything about the 90A? If so, that's going to be a problem as the list does no include a Motorola 90A alternator. A Mazda yes, but no Moto. However, there are several 95A units. So if we really want to say something about the smaller alternator I'll need some help determining which one(s) it is. If not, we can clean the information up by removing the information on it.

Donor_Vehicle_Capture.thumb.jpg.17c12597e5db77c3da5c8c72434d9920.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 78
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

The '94 service manual calls them 95A & 130A. This shows how to distinguish them quickly:

https://supermotors.net/getfile/1079023/thumbnail/3gs.jpg

For any alternator whose rear case isn't rotated (clocked) for your application, the rear case (with stator inside) can be separated & rotated in relation to the front (with most of the mounting points). So IDK if your donor list only includes those with the correct clocking or just all 130A 3Gs, but it SHOULD include all.

For the ammeter...

If it's the same as my '83's original (shunted voltmeter labelled in Amps, supplied by tiny harness wires), then no action is necessary. It may peg with the 3G's higher output, but that won't hurt THE METER or the alt. If it's an inductive ammeter (not actually connected to the wiring; just a heavy pass-through loop), that also can't be hurt by a HO alt. But I don't think Ford used that in the 80s (the '66-77 Bronco might have been the last application for that). The only type that WOULD be damaged is a full-current ammeter (heavy studs & wire) since it's not made to handle significantly more than its full range can display. But I don't think any of these trucks were built with that type.

As to the factory wiring...

As long as no additional loads are installed ON the factory wiring (this means the new alt, too), no additional current will flow through the factory harness, and no changes are necessary. All new or larger-than-factory loads should begin with a new fuse/fusible link from the B+ side of the starter relay, directly against the alternator output ring terminal. And they should return to the battery negative terminal, or to one of the heavy rings on that cable (frame or block). If new loads MUST be added through the factory wiring, then the alternator is irrelevant - the factory circuits MUST be analyzed & adapted for those loads. This explains the proper way to put a 3G onto a '66-77 Bronco, which is virtually identical to the installation in a bullnose:

https://supermotors.net/getfile/870470/thumbnail/3gswap.jpg

The ignition switch is substantially different, but no connections actually need to be made there. The voltmeter can be connected to the switched circuit on the instrument cluster (Bk/LG 40, pin 1).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The '94 service manual calls them 95A & 130A. This shows how to distinguish them quickly:

https://supermotors.net/getfile/1079023/thumbnail/3gs.jpg

For any alternator whose rear case isn't rotated (clocked) for your application, the rear case (with stator inside) can be separated & rotated in relation to the front (with most of the mounting points). So IDK if your donor list only includes those with the correct clocking or just all 130A 3Gs, but it SHOULD include all.

For the ammeter...

If it's the same as my '83's original (shunted voltmeter labelled in Amps, supplied by tiny harness wires), then no action is necessary. It may peg with the 3G's higher output, but that won't hurt THE METER or the alt. If it's an inductive ammeter (not actually connected to the wiring; just a heavy pass-through loop), that also can't be hurt by a HO alt. But I don't think Ford used that in the 80s (the '66-77 Bronco might have been the last application for that). The only type that WOULD be damaged is a full-current ammeter (heavy studs & wire) since it's not made to handle significantly more than its full range can display. But I don't think any of these trucks were built with that type.

As to the factory wiring...

As long as no additional loads are installed ON the factory wiring (this means the new alt, too), no additional current will flow through the factory harness, and no changes are necessary. All new or larger-than-factory loads should begin with a new fuse/fusible link from the B+ side of the starter relay, directly against the alternator output ring terminal. And they should return to the battery negative terminal, or to one of the heavy rings on that cable (frame or block). If new loads MUST be added through the factory wiring, then the alternator is irrelevant - the factory circuits MUST be analyzed & adapted for those loads. This explains the proper way to put a 3G onto a '66-77 Bronco, which is virtually identical to the installation in a bullnose:

https://supermotors.net/getfile/870470/thumbnail/3gswap.jpg

The ignition switch is substantially different, but no connections actually need to be made there. The voltmeter can be connected to the switched circuit on the instrument cluster (Bk/LG 40, pin 1).

Steve - Thanks for the response. But there's so much in yours that I'm going to respond in two installments.

You said "So IDK if your donor list only includes those with the correct clocking or just all 130A 3Gs, but it SHOULD include all." And if by that you mean all 130A alternators with the right mounts then I fully agree. But, I can't tell from the part numbers what the mount configuration is, and we don't want to include 130A alternators that have the different mounts.

I took the original donor list and matched it up to the applications in the interchange list and found that it closely matched two different part numbers. Given that, I assumed that I had the right alternators, and proposed that list of donor vehicles.

But I have no proof that those are the right two alternators. Just a good, but not perfect, overlap of applications.

Are they clocked correctly? Dunno.

Are there others that may be clocked differently that could be used? Dunno

As said, I don't think we want to include all of the 130A alternators shown in the interchange list as there are almost certainly some in there with the wrong mounts. We can tell the reader that this list is pretty sure to have the right alternator, but that there may be other applications that use alternators that will work, and then show them the picture, again as it is already in there, of the right alternator.

I think what we may need to do is to have someone spend a day at the salvage with pics of the right alternators and just write down which vehicles have them and which don't.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The '94 service manual calls them 95A & 130A. This shows how to distinguish them quickly:

https://supermotors.net/getfile/1079023/thumbnail/3gs.jpg

For any alternator whose rear case isn't rotated (clocked) for your application, the rear case (with stator inside) can be separated & rotated in relation to the front (with most of the mounting points). So IDK if your donor list only includes those with the correct clocking or just all 130A 3Gs, but it SHOULD include all.

For the ammeter...

If it's the same as my '83's original (shunted voltmeter labelled in Amps, supplied by tiny harness wires), then no action is necessary. It may peg with the 3G's higher output, but that won't hurt THE METER or the alt. If it's an inductive ammeter (not actually connected to the wiring; just a heavy pass-through loop), that also can't be hurt by a HO alt. But I don't think Ford used that in the 80s (the '66-77 Bronco might have been the last application for that). The only type that WOULD be damaged is a full-current ammeter (heavy studs & wire) since it's not made to handle significantly more than its full range can display. But I don't think any of these trucks were built with that type.

As to the factory wiring...

As long as no additional loads are installed ON the factory wiring (this means the new alt, too), no additional current will flow through the factory harness, and no changes are necessary. All new or larger-than-factory loads should begin with a new fuse/fusible link from the B+ side of the starter relay, directly against the alternator output ring terminal. And they should return to the battery negative terminal, or to one of the heavy rings on that cable (frame or block). If new loads MUST be added through the factory wiring, then the alternator is irrelevant - the factory circuits MUST be analyzed & adapted for those loads. This explains the proper way to put a 3G onto a '66-77 Bronco, which is virtually identical to the installation in a bullnose:

https://supermotors.net/getfile/870470/thumbnail/3gswap.jpg

The ignition switch is substantially different, but no connections actually need to be made there. The voltmeter can be connected to the switched circuit on the instrument cluster (Bk/LG 40, pin 1).

Ok Steve, now for Installment 2: The Wiring.

The Bullnose ammeters are all the same, just like your 83's. For others, since you know this, here's how the wiring looks like with the regulator and its wiring removed for simplicity. And the way it works is that any current across the shunt creates a voltage that gets registered by the "ammeter". If the current flows from left to right, which means it is flowing out of the battery, then the ammeter registers discharge. And if it flows from right to left across the shunt, meaning the battery is being charged, then that's what the ammeter registers.

Base_Wiring_Capture_-_Shunt_Highlightedjpg.thumb.jpg.53ac351df97d703821ed125d76c7800b.jpg

But let's assume that we replace the 1G alternator with a 130A-capable 3G and wire it the same as the factory did and have no additional electrical load in the cab. As shown below, the current to the battery will be from the ammeter through the shunt, and in normal situations all will be well. However, what if we have a dead or bad battery? The alternator will go full-tilt and with the right engine RPM's it'll kick out all 130 amps. But by my estimation that shunt is sized to handle ~70 amps, which is the largest alternators these trucks came with. I do not think that shunt will handle the load and the insulation will melt. I know that can happen because I recently helped a young man with melted wiring and he admitted he'd just replaced the alternator with a 3G - without taking the shunt out of the current's path. And I've heard of it happening to others as well.

Base_Wiring_Capture_-_Flow_Thru_Shunt.thumb.jpg.39e1bfe8efe2a69ef24d494d84614e3a.jpg

However, you suggested recently that we take the alternator's output to the relay's always-hot post. And, assuming that people do as you suggest and don't connect any additional loads to the stock wiring, that solves the problem because, as shown below, the current to charge the battery does not go through the shunt. However, whatever current is flowing to the cab will always show as a discharge on the ammeter, so if even just the engine is running there will be a slight discharge.

That's not the "clean" way to do it in my opinion as I think it is better to convert the ammeter to a voltmeter, but some people don't want to bother to do that. So at least this approach will keep them from burning up their wiring.

And, if you are going to turn the ammeter into a voltmeter, like I'm doing, this is the way to do it as well. The shunt won't be hurt with the current for the normal accessories, and you can use the red/orange wire as the positive lead to the voltmeter.

Thoughts?

Base_Wiring_Capture_-_Flow_Past_Shunt.thumb.jpg.c2369bbc77a1d5b263a3afbf2a6cf21e.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

...just replaced the alternator with a 3G - without taking the shunt out of the current's path.
That's why, in my first reply, I mentioned that a higher-than-factory alt counts as "additional load".
...take the alternator's output to the relay's always-hot post.
It surprises me that anyone would try or even THINK that the old Bk/Or wire would be a good place to connect a 3G, if they saw the 3G's original output wire (presumably while removing the 3G at the JY). And as easy as it is to pull a 3G harness (1 starter relay nut & 1 easy connector on the LG/R wire), I really can't imagine any easier or more-obvious way to do the swap.
That's not the "clean" way to do it in my opinion as I think it is better to convert the ammeter to a voltmeter...
That's a separate issue from the alternator wiring, and the wiring for additional loads. A voltmeter is neither a significant new load, nor a requirement for a 3G to work. But I recommended the voltmeter in my first reply.
...this approach will keep them from burning up their wiring.

And, if you are going to turn the ammeter into a voltmeter, like I'm doing, this is the way to do it as well.

I'm not sure which approach, and which way to do it you mean there. The approach in your diagram above; the way in your diagram below; or were you still referring to my post?
...use the red/orange wire as the positive lead to the voltmeter.
That's not correct. The factory ammeter wires are always hot. The voltmeter should be switched, as I described in my first reply. It's very easy to solder a new wire to the ICVR's brass button on the film circuit. Just be sure to put it on the INPUT side (steady 12V). For convenience, the voltmeter negative can go to the ICVR's mounting/grounding screw.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Gary, I would consider myself more of a consumer of this page than a contributor, as I have not actually done a 3G swap, and I would definitely need help getting it wired in correctly. That said, I can give my input regarding what I think would be useful.

When you walk out onto the pick ‘n pull lot, it is probably going to take you more time to verify the model year and engine of the car than to just check the alternator and see if it is the right type. Not that a comprehensive list isn’t useful, but the bottom line is to be able to ID the alternator. If I went hunting I would probably poke my nose under the hood of all large-ish 90’s Ford’s and what I would need would be clear photos showing what I want and don’t want and how to tell them apart.

Where you want/need an exact year, model, and engine size is if you choose to order an alternator online or through a parts house. In that case, you do need the correct application details. But ONE correct application is enough.

Regarding the ammeter issue, I think folks just need to realize that ~something needs to be done, and what the options are (even if it’s just to disconnect it to prevent meltdown). Having pulled quite a few instrument clusters, I can say that several have had burnt circuit films going to the ammeter. I can’t really speculate what the cause is (with a stock alternator) but this is one more argument in favor of switching to a volt meter or aftermarket ammeter that does not use the stock gauge wiring.

The other thing that I believe would help folks is a reference to convert a 3G to V belts. Maybe it is only the IDI, but I remember reading that you needed to find a pulley with the right amount of offset, and that was from some odd Dodge application. I will try to dig that up, vague though it was. Do you know if that is the case with the gas engines? Or can you remove and use the 1G or 2G pulley if you are running V belts?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

...just replaced the alternator with a 3G - without taking the shunt out of the current's path.
That's why, in my first reply, I mentioned that a higher-than-factory alt counts as "additional load".
...take the alternator's output to the relay's always-hot post.
It surprises me that anyone would try or even THINK that the old Bk/Or wire would be a good place to connect a 3G, if they saw the 3G's original output wire (presumably while removing the 3G at the JY). And as easy as it is to pull a 3G harness (1 starter relay nut & 1 easy connector on the LG/R wire), I really can't imagine any easier or more-obvious way to do the swap.
That's not the "clean" way to do it in my opinion as I think it is better to convert the ammeter to a voltmeter...
That's a separate issue from the alternator wiring, and the wiring for additional loads. A voltmeter is neither a significant new load, nor a requirement for a 3G to work. But I recommended the voltmeter in my first reply.
...this approach will keep them from burning up their wiring.

And, if you are going to turn the ammeter into a voltmeter, like I'm doing, this is the way to do it as well.

I'm not sure which approach, and which way to do it you mean there. The approach in your diagram above; the way in your diagram below; or were you still referring to my post?
...use the red/orange wire as the positive lead to the voltmeter.
That's not correct. The factory ammeter wires are always hot. The voltmeter should be switched, as I described in my first reply. It's very easy to solder a new wire to the ICVR's brass button on the film circuit. Just be sure to put it on the INPUT side (steady 12V). For convenience, the voltmeter negative can go to the ICVR's mounting/grounding screw.

I was asked to throw my $.02 into this discussion. Biggest issue I saw in doing mine, in addition to the pulley issue with V-belts. The shunt for the ammeter is a limiting factor as Steve points out. In order to get the voltage drop (which is what the "ammeter" is measuring) the shunt is sized to provide a good deflection at maximum load in either direction. I actually talked to an electrical engineer trying to come up with a decent solution, which basically boiled down to "if you increase the shunt size you loose sensitivity to smaller loads". This means a small discharge condition may no be immediately evident.

That being said, his recommendation was to simply bypass the shunt and add a voltmeter to the truck. The voltmeter conversion, provided it is wired for key on only operation is a great modification, good enough that Ford did it staring in 1987.

Ammeters were a valuable indicator in the days of 25-35 amp generators and were frequently always hot meaning the generator (or alternator on Chrysler products) was in series with the load and output. Power from the generator went through the ammeter then to the electrical loads so a discharge actually meant you were running on the battery as the generator output was too low, charge meant the generator was providing more current then what was needed for the loads and was charging the battery.

Side note, my first truck, a 1958 F100, had a 25 amp Ford generator. It originally just had two idiot lights and a temperature and gas gauge. I scored an instrument cluster from an F600 in a junk yard with full gauges and installed it. Winter driving, after a week of in town, if I didn't get on the interstate and drive it a good ways, midway through the second week, it would get very slow to crank.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was asked to throw my $.02 into this discussion. Biggest issue I saw in doing mine, in addition to the pulley issue with V-belts. The shunt for the ammeter is a limiting factor as Steve points out. In order to get the voltage drop (which is what the "ammeter" is measuring) the shunt is sized to provide a good deflection at maximum load in either direction. I actually talked to an electrical engineer trying to come up with a decent solution, which basically boiled down to "if you increase the shunt size you loose sensitivity to smaller loads". This means a small discharge condition may no be immediately evident.

That being said, his recommendation was to simply bypass the shunt and add a voltmeter to the truck. The voltmeter conversion, provided it is wired for key on only operation is a great modification, good enough that Ford did it staring in 1987.

Ammeters were a valuable indicator in the days of 25-35 amp generators and were frequently always hot meaning the generator (or alternator on Chrysler products) was in series with the load and output. Power from the generator went through the ammeter then to the electrical loads so a discharge actually meant you were running on the battery as the generator output was too low, charge meant the generator was providing more current then what was needed for the loads and was charging the battery.

Side note, my first truck, a 1958 F100, had a 25 amp Ford generator. It originally just had two idiot lights and a temperature and gas gauge. I scored an instrument cluster from an F600 in a junk yard with full gauges and installed it. Winter driving, after a week of in town, if I didn't get on the interstate and drive it a good ways, midway through the second week, it would get very slow to crank.

Ok, I think we now have enough varying views that we can sorta pull things together. Let me address a few things from what each of you have said, but I'm sure I'll miss some of your favorite points:

Steve - I have seen people wire a 130A alternator to the existing alternator lead, so I think it is important that we tell them not to do that, and why.

As for using the red/orange wire to run the voltmeter, I want to use that for two reasons. First, because I want to know the battery voltage and not the voltage in the cab. The wiring to the cab is, in my opinion, less than adequate, and coupled with marginal switches and varying current loads, causes the voltage in the cab to vary significantly. So I want to know what the battery is "seeing". Big Blue's aftermarket voltmeter was wired to the fuse block when I got him and it always read low enough to cause concern on my part.

Second, using that wire means I don't have to run another wire to the voltmeter. But, I think you misunderstood my intent, which was to install a key-on relay in that wire - although I didn't say that. Or, maybe put a key-on relay in the dash to provide the ground to the voltmeter? You have to be in there changing the ground side of the gauge anyway, so.....

Also, I wouldn't want to use power from the ICVR. There is an "8 to 9 ohm" resistance in the feed to the ICVR (see Pg 98), and since the gauges can pull about an amp each that would cause a significant voltage drop.

But I think overall we are in agreement.

Jonathan - As we've discussed on the side, the current page does have some pics of the alternators as well as a discussion of the pulleys. But you've volunteered to get more of pictures when you are able to get to the salvage, which we can certainly use. And if you find the discussion of the IDI pulley issue we can take that into account.

Bill - I went through exactly the same thinking as your engineer friend regarding replacing the current (pun intended) shunt and came to the same conclusion. Any shunt that would give the same voltage drop across it as the current shunt but with twice the alternator output wouldn't show anything noticeable if the alternator died and you just had a few accessories on. I even explored using a Schottky diode in parallel to the shunt to carry the charging load but allow the shunt to work in the discharge direction. But the voltage drop across the diodes isn't linear so that wouldn't work. However, having another shunt in series with the diode and having that combo in parallel with the original shunt would work. But it was too complex and I finally decided the voltmeter would be easier and better.

All - Let me work on the page and get back with you. Unfortunately I'll actually have to either modify the current (:nabble_smiley_cool:) page or, maybe duplicate it and hide the test one, as I can't really show you my plans here in this thread. Thanks for the help. :nabble_anim_working:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

...I want to know the battery voltage and not the voltage in the cab. The wiring to the cab is, in my opinion, less than adequate...
But then you're talking about using the factory wiring to the cab - the ammeter wiring. No matter what wiring you use, you're always getting voltage "in the cab" if that's where the gauge is.
...I don't have to run another wire to the voltmeter.

...

You have to be in there changing the ground side of the gauge anyway, so...

So why not just run the wiring the way it needs to be? You have to run 2 wires to the voltmeter no matter what - it's not going to attach to the film circuit. So it's not "another" wire to the voltmeter - it's just one of the 2 that are required. And they don't have to be big - telephone wire is big enough (if anyone remembers what THAT is! :nabble_smiley_grin:).
...install a key-on relay in that wire - although I didn't say that. Or, maybe put a key-on relay in the dash to provide the ground to the voltmeter?
It doesn't matter which side of the voltmeter is switched - every additional connection & switch in the circuit adds resistance. But the ig.sw. is self-cleaning, and built to handle a lot of current. So it's the best switch to turn the voltmeter on. If there's resistance in the stock wiring, fix that. Adding more wiring to bypass problems is just adding more problems.
There is an "8 to 9 ohm" resistance in the feed to the ICVR (see Pg 98)...
There's at least one BIG error in that diagram, so that resistor might be another. Haynes doesn't show it, and I can't imagine why it would be there, in addition to the ICVR. I don't recall my truck having it.
...since the gauges can pull about an amp each that would cause a significant voltage drop.
I'm not sure where you're getting those numbers, but that would mean each gauge averages 5 Ohms, which seems VERY low to me. Especially considering that the fuel sender alone can't go below ~20 Ohms. At 5V, that would limit its max current (even if the gauge had 0 Ohms) to 0.25 Ohms.

My point is: you're in there "fixing" the wiring anyway - why not do it right and fix it all? Don't work around other problems just because they're common & not directly-related to this swap.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

...I want to know the battery voltage and not the voltage in the cab. The wiring to the cab is, in my opinion, less than adequate...
But then you're talking about using the factory wiring to the cab - the ammeter wiring. No matter what wiring you use, you're always getting voltage "in the cab" if that's where the gauge is.
...I don't have to run another wire to the voltmeter.

...

You have to be in there changing the ground side of the gauge anyway, so...

So why not just run the wiring the way it needs to be? You have to run 2 wires to the voltmeter no matter what - it's not going to attach to the film circuit. So it's not "another" wire to the voltmeter - it's just one of the 2 that are required. And they don't have to be big - telephone wire is big enough (if anyone remembers what THAT is! :nabble_smiley_grin:).
...install a key-on relay in that wire - although I didn't say that. Or, maybe put a key-on relay in the dash to provide the ground to the voltmeter?
It doesn't matter which side of the voltmeter is switched - every additional connection & switch in the circuit adds resistance. But the ig.sw. is self-cleaning, and built to handle a lot of current. So it's the best switch to turn the voltmeter on. If there's resistance in the stock wiring, fix that. Adding more wiring to bypass problems is just adding more problems.
There is an "8 to 9 ohm" resistance in the feed to the ICVR (see Pg 98)...
There's at least one BIG error in that diagram, so that resistor might be another. Haynes doesn't show it, and I can't imagine why it would be there, in addition to the ICVR. I don't recall my truck having it.
...since the gauges can pull about an amp each that would cause a significant voltage drop.
I'm not sure where you're getting those numbers, but that would mean each gauge averages 5 Ohms, which seems VERY low to me. Especially considering that the fuel sender alone can't go below ~20 Ohms. At 5V, that would limit its max current (even if the gauge had 0 Ohms) to 0.25 Ohms.

My point is: you're in there "fixing" the wiring anyway - why not do it right and fix it all? Don't work around other problems just because they're common & not directly-related to this swap.

First, for reference I'm quoting info from this page (Electrical/Gauges) and the Gauge Circuits & Spec's tab, which shows the results of my testing of the gauges and wiring harness, and refers to the ICVR page with discusses my testing of that monstrosity. :nabble_smiley_argh: Some time ago I got tired of doing tests and then losing the results, so have been documenting my testing for posterity.

But then you're talking about using the factory wiring to the cab - the ammeter wiring. No matter what wiring you use, you're always getting voltage "in the cab" if that's where the gauge is.
Depending your definition, yes it could be considered the voltage "in the cab", but it will be measuring the voltage effectively at the battery since the red/orange wire connects essentially to the hot terminal of the starter relay. And, my testing shows that the ammeter Rocketman converted to a voltmeter for me only pulls ~80 ma, so there will effectively be no voltage drop on that wire to the ammeter since there is nothing else on that wire. In other words, it will be reading battery voltage.

Having said that, 80 ma is too much current to be pulling all the time, so I agree that a relay is required. And for that I'm considering placing a relay in/under the dash to switch the ground to the voltmeter. And, I may take the pull-in current from the black/light green wire which is going to the hot side of the ICVR - as you suggested. :nabble_smiley_good:

So why not just run the wiring the way it needs to be? You have to run 2 wires to the voltmeter no matter what - it's not going to attach to the film circuit. So it's not "another" wire to the voltmeter - it's just one of the 2 that are required. And they don't have to be big - telephone wire is big enough (if anyone remembers what THAT is! :nabble_smiley_grin:).
I really don't have to run any wires to the voltmeter. As said, the red/orange wire will bring battery voltage right through the film circuit to the voltmeter. And I'll break into the yellow/light green wire in the harness prior to the connector to the cluster and install the relay and ground circuit, so the yellow/light green wire will bring ground to the voltmeter, right through the film. That way there's no change to the cluster itself but installing the voltmeter.

It doesn't matter which side of the voltmeter is switched - every additional connection & switch in the circuit adds resistance. But the ig.sw. is self-cleaning, and built to handle a lot of current. So it's the best switch to turn the voltmeter on. If there's resistance in the stock wiring, fix that. Adding more wiring to bypass problems is just adding more problems.
As said, there's so little current being pulled for the voltmeter that the skinny little red/orange wire won't have enough voltage drop to worry about. And there are no switches nor other wires to go through but the relay and its ground.

There's at least one BIG error in that diagram, so that resistor might be another. Haynes doesn't show it, and I can't imagine why it would be there, in addition to the ICVR. I don't recall my truck having it.
That resistor is there, as you can see on the Gauges page. My DVM registered 8.9 ohms, which is what the all the EVTM's show as well as both the '85 and '86 Wiring Diagrams show at D13 on Page 1.

I'm not sure where you're getting those numbers, but that would mean each gauge averages 5 Ohms, which seems VERY low to me. Especially considering that the fuel sender alone can't go below ~20 Ohms. At 5V, that would limit its max current (even if the gauge had 0 Ohms) to 0.25 Ohms.
Well, my numbers for current draw were off. :nabble_smiley_blush: As you can see from the Gauges page, each gauge pulls about .2 amp, not the 1 amp I was remembering. But the fuel senders run from 10 ohms to 73 ohms, also shown on the Gauges page. And the gauges run about 12 ohms themselves.

My point is: you're in there "fixing" the wiring anyway - why not do it right and fix it all? Don't work around other problems just because they're common & not directly-related to this swap.
I think I am fixing the wiring correctly, but that's my opinion and not everyone will agree with me. I plan to use the factory's hot wire to the gauge and switch the ground with a relay triggered by key'd power. No wires to run through the firewall and nothing to change other than the ammeter to a voltmeter and the ground circuit.

Ok, all of that is really about how I want to put a voltmeter in the system. But now let's turn to the 3G page "upgrades". I've duplicated the existing page and have hidden it in the menu - two ways:

So, I'd like everyone's input as to which approach seems best - tabbed or loooong paaaaaggggeeee. :nabble_smiley_beam:

I'll work in the background as I can to "upgrade" what is one of our most popular pages on the website. Let's see if we can't make it a bit better.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites


×
×
  • Create New...