The hard plastic ones in your pic look very similar to the originals. But the carpet ones don't. I've included a pic from the 1985 brochure of what the originals looked like. And I like the look of the original better than the new carpet ones.
I've had both. The plastic ones hold a lot more than the carpet ones. But, being plastic, they can be noisy as things in them bounce and rattle. However, they don't seem to get in the way or crowd things.
The original plastic ones were a bit brittle, or maybe I should say they are by now. And if you don't get your foot out of the way when closing the door you can crack them. The least strong spot is right along the top inner edge, which is about where they hit your foot or leg. I've repaired and reinforced them by gluing a strip of metal laid on its side in that top edge, and it really helped.
The original carpet ones will hold a pair of gloves or two, a few sheets of paper, or maybe a small book. And they have elastic in them so they go back flat when things are taken out. But they aren't nearly as useful as the plastic ones. I could see placing your lunch in a plastic one and pulling it out as you drive. Not sure that would work with the carpet ones.
Gary, AKA "Gary fellow":
Profile
Dad's: '81 F150 Ranger XLT 4x4: Down for restomod: Full-roller "stroked 351M" w/Trick Flow heads & intake, EEC-V SEFI/E4OD/3.50 gears w/Kevlar clutches
Blue: 2015 F150 Platinum 4x4 SuperCrew wearing Blue Jeans & sporting a 3.5L EB & Max Tow
Big Blue: 1985 F250HD 4x4: 460/ZF5/3.55's, D60 w/Ox locker & 10.25 Sterling/Trutrac, Blue Top & Borgeson, & EEC-V MAF/SEFI